Summary & Analysis

Measure for Measure, Act 4 Scene 2 — Summary & Analysis

Setting: A room in the prison Who's in it: Provost, Pompey, Abhorson, Claudio, Duke vincentio, Messenger Reading time: ~11 min

What happens

The Provost offers Pompey a chance to avoid whipping by becoming the executioner's assistant. Pompey agrees. Angelo's messenger arrives with a written order: execute both Claudio and Barnardine by set times, and send Claudio's head to Angelo by five o'clock. The Duke, disguised as a friar, reveals he knows Angelo's true nature and instructs the Provost to execute Barnardine instead, disguise the head, and hide both Claudio and Barnardine alive. The Provost reluctantly agrees.

Why it matters

This scene orchestrates the play's central deception. Pompey's transition from pimp to executioner's assistant is absurdly comic yet philosophically apt—he shifts from profiting off sin to profiting off punishment, yet remains fundamentally unchanged. The scene's dark humor masks a deeper question about justice and redemption: can anyone, no matter how fallen, find a place in society? The Provost's reluctant participation reveals the machinery of state power that the Duke controls from behind his friar's disguise, showing how authority operates through subterfuge rather than transparency.

The Duke's emergence as the true manipulator is complete here. He rewrites Angelo's orders without authority, yet carries seals and signatures that compel obedience. His scheme relies on substituting one corpse for another—Ragozine's head for Claudio's—a grotesque literalization of theatrical trick-work. This turn exposes the play's deepest concern: that justice is performance, that truth can be manufactured through careful staging. The Provost's fear and compliance, despite his moral qualms, shows how power silences conscience. By the scene's end, Claudio is secretly alive, Angelo's order corrupted, and the stage set for revelation. The Duke has become what he claimed to hate—a man who uses deception to enforce his will, even if toward seemingly good ends.

Key quotes from this scene

A bawd, sir? fie upon him! he will discredit our mystery.

A pimp, sir? Shame on him! He’ll ruin our profession.

Abhorson · Act 4, Scene 2

Abhorson recoils when told that Pompey, a pimp, will become his assistant executioner. The line lands because it reveals the rigid social hierarchies of the play—even criminals judge each other by profession, and Abhorson sees Pompey's trade as beneath his own. It shows that in Vienna, shame is not about the act itself but about which acts society permits and which it forbids.

Do you call, sir?

Did you call, sir?

Abhorson · Act 4, Scene 2

Abhorson, the prison executioner, responds to the Provost's summons with this simple question. The line matters because it establishes Abhorson as a tradesman with professional pride—someone who takes his grim work seriously and expects to be addressed with respect. It tells us that even in the darkest corners of Vienna's justice system, people cling to dignity and the rituals of their calling.

Every true man’s apparel fits your thief: if it be too little for your thief, your true man thinks it big enough; if it be too big for your thief, your thief thinks it little enough: so every true man’s apparel fits your thief.

Every honest man’s clothes fit your thief: if they’re too small for your thief, the honest man thinks they’re big enough; if they’re too big for your thief, the thief thinks they’re small enough: so every honest man’s clothes fit your thief.

Abhorson · Act 4, Scene 2

Abhorson delivers this riddling speech about how honest clothes fit both honest men and thieves equally well, depending on what the wearer thinks. The line endures because it is the play's clearest statement about disguise and seeming—appearance is meaningless without intent, and the same external form can contain opposite natures. It captures the play's obsession with the gap between what we are and what we appear to be.

Read this scene →

Original Shakespeare alongside modern English. Synced read-along narration in the app.

In the app

Hear Act 4, Scene 2, narrated.

Synced read-along narration: every line of this scene, words highlighting as they're spoken — so you can read along without losing the line.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play