Summary & Analysis

Richard III, Act 1 Scene 4 — Summary & Analysis

Setting: London. The Tower Who's in it: Brakenbury, Clarence, First murderer, Second murderer, Both Reading time: ~15 min

What happens

Clarence, imprisoned in the Tower, confides his nightmares to Brakenbury—visions of drowning in the sea and encountering the ghosts of those he's wronged. Two murderers arrive with Richard's warrant. Clarence pleads for his life, invoking God's law and his own conscience, but they silence him with violence. One murderer hesitates, troubled by guilt, but the other proceeds. Clarence is drowned in a butt of malmsey wine, fulfilling Richard's hidden plot.

Why it matters

Clarence's drowning dream dominates this scene and stands as one of Shakespeare's most remarkable passages—a baroque vision of underwater horror that anticipates his actual death moments later. The dream is not mere decoration: it reveals Clarence's guilty conscience and establishes the play's central moral truth: that blood spilled in the Wars of the Roses demands repayment. When Clarence describes jewels and gold scattered among the skulls of drowned men, he's not fantasizing—he's prophesying his own doom. The dream's lyrical beauty contrasts sharply with the violence that follows, making the murder seem doubly brutal. Shakespeare uses this technique throughout the play: the inner life of conscience exposed through language, then silenced by force.

The murderers' dialogue reveals the play's interest in moral weakness and persuasion. The Second Murderer begins with genuine scruples—he invokes God's law, asks about judgment, even feels remorse—but Richard's gold and the promise of reward systematize his conscience away. He speaks of the conscience as if it's a removable thing, something that can be pocketed or forgotten. This is how Richard corrupts his allies: not through ideology but through pragmatism and payment. Yet the scene also shows the limits of Richard's power: even with a warrant and soldiers, even with Clarence helpless and alone, the murder requires effort and duplicity. The Second Murderer's final departure suggests he cannot live with what he's done, hinting that Richard's victories contain the seeds of his undoing.

Key quotes from this scene

Are you call’d forth from out a world of men To slay the innocent? What is my offence? Where are the evidence that do accuse me? What lawful quest have given their verdict up Unto the frowning judge? or who pronounced The bitter sentence of poor Clarence’ death? Before I be convict by course of law, To threaten me with death is most unlawful. I charge you, as you hope to have redemption By Christ’s dear blood shed for our grievous sins, That you depart and lay no hands on me The deed you undertake is damnable.

Are you called out from the world of men To kill an innocent person? What have I done wrong? Where’s the evidence against me? What legal process has passed judgment on me To the harsh judge? Or who declared The cruel sentence of poor Clarence’s death? Before I’m convicted by law, To threaten me with death is totally illegal. I swear to you, as you hope for salvation Through Christ’s blood shed for our sins, That you leave me alone and don’t lay a hand on me. The act you’re about to commit is damnable.

George, Duke of Clarence · Act 1, Scene 4

Clarence, facing his murderers, appeals to law and to God, asking on what lawful authority he can be condemned to death without trial. The speech endures because Clarence is right—the deed is unlawful, and he knows it—yet this knowledge saves him nothing. It shows a man of principle confronting the fact that law and justice have been severed from power.

’Faith, some certain dregs of conscience are yet within me.

Honestly, some lingering guilt is still inside me.

Second Murderer · Act 1, Scene 4

The Second Murderer admits that conscience still lingers in him, even as he prepares to drown Clarence. The line matters because it shows that even in hired killers, doubt exists—conscience cannot be entirely suppressed, only beaten down. It reveals the human cost of Richard's ambition: men who murder against their nature because they have been taught that obedience trumps morality.

I would he knew that I had saved his brother! Take thou the fee, and tell him what I say; For I repent me that the duke is slain.

I wish he knew that I saved his brother! Take the payment, and tell him what I’ve said; For I regret that the duke is dead.

Second Murderer · Act 1, Scene 4

The Second Murderer, having killed Clarence, wishes his master knew that he saved Clarence's brother instead of following orders. The line grips because it shows remorse emerging too late, after the deed is done and cannot be undone. It demonstrates how conscience, once a man is committed to murder, becomes a torture with no exit.

Read this scene →

Original Shakespeare alongside modern English. Synced read-along narration in the app.

In the app

Hear Act 1, Scene 4, narrated.

Synced read-along narration: every line of this scene, words highlighting as they're spoken — so you can read along without losing the line.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play